"VeteranexperimentalfilmmakersDanielleHuilletandJean-MarieStraubhelmedthisunusualadaptationofanovelbyElioVittorini.FocusedonthetriumphsandfailuresofagroupoflaborersandfarmhandswhopooledtheirresourcestooperateanalternativecollectivefarmaftertheendofWorldWarII,Operai,Contadinifeaturesacastof12actorswhoreadaloudfromVittorini'sbookforthedurationofthefilm,eitherrecitingfrommemoryorusingaclearlyvisiblescript.Hardlydesignedtobeacrowdpleaser,Operai,Contadiniprovedtobecontroversialamongtheaudiencesforitsshowingsatthe2001CannesFilmFestival,whereitwasscreenedaspartoftheDirectors'Fortnightseries."~MarkDeming,AllMovieGuide
"Thegroupmakesupaprimitivecommunitywhichseekstoerasenotonlythedistresscreatedbythewarbutalsothehardshipsoflifeandhunger,andtoprotectthemfromviolence,miseryandfear.Amidtheruinsofthispost-warperiod,thecharactersbuildandinventarapport bothintheirprofessionalanddailylives betweenthemselves,thesexes,generations,diversesocialandgeographicalorigins,andantagonisticpoliticalcamps.
Thegroupmaintainsa'register',akindofdiary,asifitwereenteringtheminutesofaninquiryoratrial."-SteveGrayson
"myfavoriteStraub-HuilletfilmsareTooEarly,TooLateandOperai,contadini(2001),bothcolorlandscapefilmswithespeciallyacutesensesofplaceaswellasofnatureinallitsharshbeauty."-JonathanRosenbaum
决心把已经付了钱的电影票看完后就拉黑斯特罗布呵呵呵呵……
per Faccia Cattiva e Spine Angela Nugara, per sempre
7.3/10。①二战后意大利一群工人/农民男女集中资源经营一集体农庄过程中的各种合作、困境、矛盾。②声音上是各种抑扬顿挫颇具音乐性的念白，画面上要么是各种剧情扮演要么是用法常规但颇有味道的空镜头。③施特劳布夫妇以大量原地不动（有时会肢体运动）的角色表演（以及角色们克制的表演模式）塑造庄严感（正如故事主题的严肃性），以极简的置景和干净简约的摄影美术营造一种更纯粹的情绪感受与精神体验（同质于《词语》），并在这些形式的基础上以较舒适的音响和②所说的念白方式为影像提供最主要的情绪魅力与诗意。④影像上的情绪冲击力不
修复画质124分钟版，可能我的电影欣赏水平太低了吧，看得哈欠连连，不太能接受这种表现形式。
Evilly ☣ 2018-03-29 20:16:16
港真，对比起来说，戈达尔的大部分片都蛮友好的了。Straub–Huillet真是越来越走火入魔，简直是丧心病狂了惹。